Crooked lines   113115
previous panorama
next panorama
Details / LabelsDetails / Labels Markers on / offMarkers on / off Overview on / offOverview on / off   
 Cycle through labels:   first previous stop
play
pause
next last
  zoom out
 

Labels

1 Fernsehturm
2 Kollhoff Tower
3 DB Tower
4 Sony Center

Details

Location: Berlin (Holocaust-Mahnmal)      by: Giuseppe Marzulli
Area: Germany      Date: 18 July 2014
We are in the heart of Berlin, very close to Branderburg Tor. The "Denkmal für die ermordeten Juden Europas" also known as the Holocaust Memorial (Holocaust-Mahnmal), is a memorial in Berlin to the Jewish victims of the Holocaust, designed by architect Peter Eisenman and engineer Buro Happold.

It consists of a 19.000 m2 site covered with 2.711 concrete slabs or "stelae", arranged in a grid pattern on a sloping field. The stelae are all 2,38m long and 0,95m wide, but vary in height from 0,2 to 4,8m.

Generally, from the architectural point of view, the Memorial do not like to Berliners and do not like even to tourists. This is demonstrated, for example, by the fact that no one has ever thought to photograph it in this site. In this case, my opinion is different. The Memorial do not like because it is done on purpose to confuse and embarrass. This was precisely the aim of the author.

According to Eisenman's project text, the stelae are designed to produce an uneasy, confusing atmosphere, and the whole sculpture aims to represent a supposedly ordered system that has lost touch with human reason (the Nazism).

The plan of the monument has in fact a regular pattern to the board, as the plant of certain ancient Greek and Roman cities. But it is not adjust the vertical pattern, because the stele, all equal at the base, are all different for the height and the slight tilt, thus creating an unpredictable and tormented form. Even the alleys, of equal width, paved with gray cubes hung out regularly, are not plans, but lean without apparent logic, going to sink into the ground at the highest stele. Those who love the straight lines can not fail to experience discomfort.

But not always the lines of the history are straight.

Comments

eindrucksvoll traurig!
2014/08/26 22:38 , Winfried Borlinghaus
Very impressive, in particular with this special light in the evening. Thanks for sharing this view with us, and for the elaborate description too. KR Arno
2014/08/26 22:52 , Arno Bruckardt
The night time shot without (to many) visitors makes it very special. Also taking a viewpoint showing that this site is deeply embedded into the city makes it memorable. The slabs look like coffins to me, the mobile riot control barriers disturb me more than the partying folks at the right hand side of the Memorial.

Herzlichst Christoph
2014/08/27 08:50 , Christoph Seger
Unfortunately the rudeness of some tourist is a widespread problem. But I think it is tolerable that the Memorial is used for conversation and to sit.

I believe that the decision to build a Memorial so big and so central was hard to accept for the Berliners. But I think it was a good and courageous decision.
2014/08/27 21:00 , Giuseppe Marzulli
Mille grazie per il tuo testo con molto carattere di questo posto.
Danke für den charaktervollen Text zu diesem Ort.
Thank you for the sophisticated text to this place.
Tanti saluti Wolfgang
2014/08/29 23:42 , Wolfgang Bremer
Peter Eisenman, the architect of the memorial has stated: 'The enormity and horror of the Holocaust are such that any attempt to represent it by traditional means is inevitably inadequate. I think this is a good description for this place against oblivion.
Herzliche Grüße, Matthias.
2014/08/30 00:00 , Matthias Stoffels
Il 2711 ha qualche valenza numerologica?
Non trovo nulla in proposito.
2014/09/05 11:14 , Pedrotti Alberto
2711 
I think NOW this number has a meaning. But I strongly believe (from what I read) that this was not intended ...
2014/09/05 15:20 , Christoph Seger
About the number 2711 I do not know anything.
But I can add that the memorial is built on site of Goebbels' bunker. Goebbels would surely have considered the Memorial as "entartete Kunst"...
2014/09/05 22:22 , Giuseppe Marzulli
2711 
The number of 2711 concrete slabs has no special relevance; only the site dimension and moreover geometric considerations were responsible for the amount of slabs (see https://web.archive.org/web/20110101054446/http://www.stiftung-denkmal.de/var/files/pdf-dateien/flyer_deutsch.pdf for more information.
Kind regards, Matthias.
2014/09/06 12:58 , Matthias Stoffels
Thanks for the link. Very interesting.
2014/09/06 13:43 , Giuseppe Marzulli

Leave a comment


Giuseppe Marzulli

More panoramas

... in the vicinity  
... in the top 100